Skip to content Skip to footer

Two identical charges, two different customers

In brief. The first payment can hide two opposite behaviors. The European proposal on free trials puts the customer’s consent inside the measure of conversion. It is set out in Article 20 of the proposed Digital Fairness Act, presented by the European Commission on November 11, 2026.

Two people receive the same charge. One was waiting for the deadline to keep using the service. The other had stopped opening it and realizes they still have it when they check their bank statement. In the list of conversions, the two customers occupy two identical rows.

The first bought something. The second may simply have forgotten a date. Yet that evening the revenue is the same, the campaign appears to have worked and the marketing manager can present the same result. The difference will emerge later, when one comes back to use the product and the other asks why money was taken from them.

This ambiguity enters the product directly with the Digital Fairness Act. In the proposal presented by the European Commission on November 11, 2026, Article 20 provides for a reminder before the end of the free trial and the consumer’s express consent to continue on a paid basis. It is a proposal for a regulation, not an obligation already in force. European Commission · Article 20 of the proposal

The second yes

The interesting step, for anyone who sells, is that second consent. The first yes is given to a promise: try a service, find out whether it works, see whether it solves a problem. The second comes after the customer has been able to use it. Between the two lies the work the product must do to earn a place in their day.

An invoicing application can show the invoices prepared during the trial. A training service can take the customer back to the point where they interrupted a course. These are examples of possible messages, and their quality depends on what happened before. If the only information available is the expiry date, whoever writes the email has little to tell.

Measuring that second yes means making visible a part of the value that today can remain confused with inertia. The first payment, taken alone, is an incomplete measure of the quality of the customer acquired. To judge a campaign you also need the work the customer manages to do and the time for which they choose to stay.

The European proposal contains another concrete detail: after consent, the seller must send a confirmation on a durable medium, without delay and in any case within a week. The sequence leaves a readable trace of the choice. It is a good reminder for whoever designs the experience too: the customer must know what they accepted, at what price and under what conditions. European Commission · Article 20 of the proposal

Friction has a cost even when it is right

Anyone who works on churn has a reason to worry: every added step can lose people who really do want to continue. A satisfied customer can ignore a message, read it while busy or postpone a confirmation. Not every silence hides a lack of interest. It would be convenient to describe consent as a solution that improves trust, conversions and revenue all at once. That is not a given.

This is why the commercial choice has to be assessed over time. One conversion fewer today can avoid a refund tomorrow; it can also be a legitimate sale lost to a badly designed interface. The work consists in telling the two apart, without using the difficulty of measuring as a reason not to measure.

You can compare groups of customers who arrived from the same offer, and observe how many carried out the promised activity, how many continue and how many ask for support. The comparison has to keep price, period and source similar: otherwise you end up attributing to the reminder a difference that depended on the campaign. And the count has to reach at least the first renewal, when the effect of initial enthusiasm begins to separate from usefulness.

The timing of the message deserves a test too. Reminding the customer of the choice while they are using the service can be easier to understand than chasing them with reminders unconnected to what they are doing. Clarity requires a visible price and visible conditions; adding notifications without removing ambiguity only increases the noise. Anyone who has decided to leave must be able to complete that choice without an unwanted negotiation.

If many people never reach the first result, adding a discount in the last email can cover up the problem. The point to fix may be the start: too much data requested, a step that is hard to understand, an example that does not resemble the customer’s work. Starting the trial from the first useful use, where sustainable, is also a decision about the product before it is one about communication.

If instead the customer uses the service and then leaves, it is worth taking that choice seriously. Perhaps they had an occasional need. Perhaps the recurring price does not match how often they use it. The behavior can suggest a different offer, instead of another sequence of messages to hold on to them.

Back to the two charges at the start. The invoicing software does not need to tell them apart: it has to record them correctly. Whoever runs the company, on the other hand, has every interest in knowing which of the two customers is funding growth and which is only waiting to notice the expense.

The sentence to write at the end of the trial is built in the days before. It has to be able to tell the customer something precise about what they got. If there is nothing to remind them of, the problem is not solved by choosing a better subject line.

Read next The returns page works before the sale · At eleven at night ASOS is still selling time

Background Impact · the case file (in Italian)

Image: European Commission